An excited, newly formed ball of dough, Doughbie, knows he wants to be a cookie - the only problem is he doesn't know what kind of cookie to be! A chocolate chip? Peanut butter? Snickerdoodle? Doughbie travels around the kitchen asking other foods what kind of cookie they like, filling up more and more with different ingredients to try and please everyone around him. But when Doughbie grows too big for the oven, he must decide if he will be the kind of cookie he thinks everyone else wants, or the kind he was always meant to be.