My Unfamiliar

Mara Rutherford

Book cover for My Unfamiliar
Image for variant 9781250359902
Book cover for My Unfamiliar
Image for variant 9781250359902

My Unfamiliar

My Unfamiliar

Mara Rutherford

Member Benefits

  • 30% Off All Books - Savings that support storytellers, not stock prices.
  • Fight Book Bans - Book profits fund the Rainbow Book Bus, getting banned books to LGBTQ+ youth.
Member Book Price
$21.00 $14.70
Non-Member Book Price $21.00

Membership is $14.99/month. Cancel anytime.

Already a member? Log in here.

View full details

Description

Perfect for fans of Allison Saft and Sarah Beth Durst, a grumpy mage and a familiar matchmaker navigate their surprising connection in Mara Rutherford's newest cozy fantasy.

Winslow Green is known far and wide for her ability to match mages with the perfect animal familiar. Though she doesn't possess any magic, she has a knack for knowing what her customers need, even if they can't see it themselves.

Still grieving the tragic death of his last familiar, Bastian Triplehorn reluctantly seeks Winnie's aid in finding a new partner. She's determined to live up to her reputation, despite Bastian's excessive grumpiness. Until the inexplicable happens: Bastian sparks a familiar bond with Winnie instead.

Impossible to deny, the two agree to help each other until they can solve the mystery of their connection. As Bastian and Winnie train for a royal mage competition that could solve all their problems--or ruin their lives forever--Winnie gets a taste of what it's like to have magic herself. And Bastian discovers that all of these unfamiliar feelings are a little like magic, too.

About the Author

Mara Rutherford began her writing career as a journalist but quickly discovered she far preferred fantasy to reality. Originally from California, Mara has since lived all over the world with her diplomat husband and two sons, and currently calls Rome, Italy, home. A triplet born on Leap Day, she is the author of YA fantasy novels including the Crown of Coral and Pearl duology, The Poison Season, A Multitude of Dreams, and A Curious Kind of Magic. When she's not writing, Mara can be found curled up with a good book, a cup of tea, and Mishka (a magical creature often mistaken for a dog).

Critical Reviews

"Rutherford's enchanting world has a delectable, cozy atmosphere that shifts when the characters enter the exciting, high-stakes competition, which is fraught with political intrigue and magical sabotage. Bastian and Winnie make a charming pair whose teamwork and evolving grumpy/sunshine relationship is a pleasure to witness...Enthralling and delightful." - Kirkus

"An unexpected magical bond throws two teens' futures into jeopardy in this cozy, whimsical romantasy from Rutherford...Those seeking fresh spins on familiar fantasy tropes will rejoice in this delightful offering." - Publishers Weekly

"A fun and fast-paced romantasy read filled with lighthearted high jinks and plenty of misunderstandings." - School Library Journal

"Sweet, swoony, and utterly magical, My Unfamiliar had me giggling and kicking my feet in pure delight." --Alechia Dow, author of Until the Clock Strikes Midnight

"Utterly enchanting, Rutherford's cozy fantasy easily hits every note, from the whimsical world to the swoon-worthy romance. I adored Winnie and Bastian as individuals and loved seeing their connection grow. Absolutely delightful!" - A.T Qureshi, USA Today bestselling author of the Baby Dragon series

"Wonderfully whimsical and hearts-a-flutter romantic, My Unfamiliar left me pink-cheeked with delight. I absolutely and in every way adored this story, and it's the perfect match for booklovers of all things cozy." --Heather Kassner, author of Spellwright

"My Unfamiliar has everything I love in cozy fantasy: a sweet opposites-attract romance; an atmosphere rendered in florals and pastels; and a world where love is real magic. You will be spellbound." --Allison Saft, #1 New York Times bestselling author of Wings of Starlight

"A page-turner brimming with mystery and simmering with slow-burn romance, My Unfamiliar is cozy but not too cozy, sweet but not too sweet, and perfectly, deliciously fantastical. It had me at miniature unicorn, and kept getting better and better. It's one to keep on hand to cure bad moods and make up for insufficient pinkness." - Laini Taylor, New York Times bestselling author of Daughter of Smoke & Bone

Praise for A Curious Kind of Magic:

"A Curious Kind of Magic is like a rare find in a curiosity shop--unique, intriguing, and irresistible. With a feisty heroine, a budding friendship, a warmhearted romance, and a risky hunt for a mysterious grimoire that leads to adventures and revelations, this story held me spellbound."--Elly Blake, New York Times bestselling author of The Forest King's Daughter

"A Curious Kind of Magic enchanted me from the first page. Brimming with so many bits and bobs of treasure--just like Willow's almost-magical shop!--this is a book for readers who want to root for their heroines and soak in the coziness of a slow burn fantasy. I adored it."--Erin A. Craig, #1 New York Times bestselling author of House of Roots and Ruin

"This is cozy fantasy at its best: a charming concept; an earnest, endearing heroine; and her equally lovable found family. Reading A Curious Kind of Magic feels like sipping rose hot chocolate while nestling under a fuzzy blanket on a rainy day. It made me so happy, and I can't wait for my own copy!"--Shveta Thakrar, author of the Andre Norton Nebula Award finalist Star Daughter

Publishing Information

Publisher: Wednesday Books
Pub date: 2026-12-01
Length: 352 pages

The Allstora Membership

Membership Perks:

  • Save 30% on all online store purchases
  • Exclusive access to author's content
  • You pay less, but authors still earn double

Membership Terms:

First Month: $0.00
Monthly price: $5.00
  • To access membership discount simply log in and add to cart, discount applied automatically.
  • One month free trial, cancel anytime. Membership renews on the 15th of each month.